|
MASTER PLAN NEWS 2003 October-December
This section contains news of the Master Plan, overall Bangkok development,
the Bangkok Governor's development plans, and articles about interconnecting
mass transit projects.
Mass Transit News main page
New City:
How to realize it - by Pratheep Tangmatitham
- translated and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Bangkok Biznews,
October 28, 2003
MOTC asks cabinet to repeal lift ban
on railway routes through 'A1 forests' - - translated
and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Thaipost, October 28,
2003
MOTC is asking the cabinet to repeal the cabinet resolution that stringently
prohibits bureaucrats from cutting down A1 Forests (upstream forests)
to allow bureaucrats with good reason for cutting down such virgin forests
to make the way for the projects vital to national interest--security
and economic. And allow bureaucrats to submit environmental assessment
reports to get the special approval from the cabinet on a case by case
basis.
MOTC claims that the 1989 resolution has prohibited SRT from extending
routes such as:
1) Surat Thani to Phuket via Phang Nga
2) Denchai to Chiang Rai and so on
3) Highspeed Railway from Bangkok to Khorat and so on
However, the cabinet said that good forests in Thailand cover less than
12% of land area. Therefore, the cabinet is asking SRT to make detours
unless the project is too vital to make a detour (if it is worthy for
national development). For such a special case, it will be necessary for
SRT and MOTC to come up with and Environment Impact Assessment Report
to be submitted to with Environmental Protection Committee before submitting
the plan to the cabinet.
Commentary by Wisarut: The 1989 resolution is due to disastrous
flooding in most parts of the country in 1988-1989. Furthermore, many
may still remember the expansion of the SRT network to Isan during the
1950's-1970's was a scam to cut down and clear forests on mountain sides
and leave a few stands to fool the authorities.
Raising 500 billion baht
- October 30, 2003
Local papers have finally brought up the financing of the grand mass transit
plans. As usual it is a dumbing down of what was in the Thai-language
papers weeks before, but it did have one interesting passage: Chumpol
Na Lamlieng, president of Siam Cement Plc, said he had no details on any
plan to raise money from the public to invest in transport, but said investors
would normally look for projects that yield profits.
"What we have seen so far is that most of the infrastructure projects
in Thailand face financial losses," said Chumpol. "If they make
a profit, it is not that much."
The State Railway of Thailand has been facing management problems and
consistent losses since 1973. Those losses now total Bt40 billion.
The Bangkok Mass Transit System, or BTS, which operates the Skytrain project
in Bangkok, is also facing financing losses and has been forced to negotiate
debt restructuring with creditors. ($5bn
transport funds trailed, The Nation, October 30, 2003)
Plan to invest 389 billion baht for
mass transit in Bangkok and 111 billion baht for nationwide double tracking
goes to cabinet soon - translated and summarized
by Wisarut Bholsithi from Bangkokbiznews, October 28, 2003
The Traffic Policy Office is going to submit a plan to the cabinet to
invest 500 billion baht on mass transit. 389 billion baht on 255.41 km
for Greater Bangkok and 111 billion baht for nationwide double tracking.
For the Skytrain, extension plans are:
Total - 39.40 km
Budget - 75.820 billion baht
1.1) Onnut - Samrong (Samrong Extension Phase 1) 8.9 km - 15.190 billion
baht - early 2004 to late 2006
1.2) Samrong Samut Prakarn (Samrong Extension Phase 2) 7.9 km - 13.340
billion baht - late 2004 to late 2008
1.3) Saphan Taksin - Taksin Road (Taksin Extension Phase 1) 2.2 km - 3.420
billion baht - early 2004 to late 2004
1.4) Taksin Road - Phetkasem (Taksin Extension Phase 2) 4.5 km - 7.160
billion baht - early 2004 to late 2006
1.5) Mochit - Saphan Mai (Phaholyothin Extension) 10.7 km - 19.990 billion
baht - early 2004 to late 2007
1.6) National Stadium - Pinklao - Charansanitwongse (Rattnakosin Extension)
5.5 km - 16.720 billion baht - early 2004 to late 2009
For the SRT, the elevated commuter lines would be:
Total - 114.51 km
Budget - 108.1 billion baht
2.1) Phayathai - Makkasan - NBIA (Airport Link) 28.47 km - 21.2 billion
baht - late 2004 to late 2551
2.2) Bangsue - Phyathai (Chitladda Link) 6.09 km - 7.8 billion baht -
early 2005 to late 2009
2.3) Hua Lamphong - Bangsue (Yommaraj Link) - 7.49 km - 10.6 billion baht
- early 2005 to late 2009
2.4) Bangsue - Rangsit (Northern Commuter) - 22.73 km - 26.86 billion
baht - late 2005 to late 2008
2.5) Hua Lamphong - Si Phraya - Taksin Center 6.54 km (Si Phraya Link)
8.140 billion baht - early 2005 to late 2009
2.6) Taksin Center - Mahachai - 14.93 km - 28.26 km (Southwestern Commuter)
16.7 billion baht - late 2005 to late 2009
2.7) Bangsue - Rama 6 - Talingchan (Northwestern Commuter) -14.93 km -
16.8 billion baht - late 2004 to late 2008
For the case of MRTA,
Total - 101.2 km
Budget - 204.703 billion baht
3.1) Hualamphong - Tha Phra (1st phase of Southern Extension of Blue line)
- 8 km 19.8 billion baht - mid 2004 to late 2009
3.2) Bangsue - Charansanitwongse - Tha Phra (blue line Northern Ring)
13.1 km - 19.83 billion baht - mid 2004 to late 2010
3.3) Tha Phra - Bang Wah (Southern Link & Interchange) 1.1 km - 2.72
billion baht - mid 2004 to late 2008
3.4) Bang Wah - Bang Kae (blue line Bangkhae Extension) 4.7 km - 7.42
billion baht - mid 2004 to late 2008
3.5) Bang Khae - Om Noy (blue line Om Noy Extension) 12.1 km 17.2 billion
baht - late 2004 to late 2010
3.6) Bang Kapi - Sam Sen [Sang Hee] (1st phase Orange Line) 20 km - 44.920
km - late 2004 to late 2009
3.7) Sam Sen - Bang Bumru (Orange line Krung Thon Extension) - 3 km -
11.340 billion baht - late 2004 to late 2010
3.8) Bang Yai - Phra Nangklao (Purple Line - Former Northern Extension)
- 8.1 km 11.80 billion baht - late 2004 to late 2010
3.9) Pha Nangklao - Bangsue (Purple Line - Former Northern Extension)
- 11.6 km - 16.86 billion baht - late 2004 to late 2008
3.10) Bangsue - Bang Pho - Samsen (Purple line) - 3.9 km - 11.173 billion
baht - late 2004 to late 2010
3.11) Samsen - Ratboorana [Nakhon Khuenkhan] - 15.6 km - 41.640 billion
baht - late 2004 to late 2009
New canal and river routes
- translated and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Manager Daily,
October 21, 2003
Suriya is asking for 15.88 million baht for the Marine Department to renovate
piers, develop six canals and Chao Phraya routes, and develop a new type
of boat made from fiberglass.
If the Marine Department could make a good boat service that meets safety
standards, it would encourage more people who live in canal areas to use
boats. If possible, MOTC will ask the Marine Department to run boat services
since private concession holders do not care about safety matters at all.
They are just seek profit at the expense of the passengers.
For the Saensaeb boat service run by Krobkrua Transport, the piers and
the boats must be improved to meet higher safety standards and give more
confidence to passengers. The public sector will initiate this project
by designing a prototype boat and then the government will invite the
private sector to invest in this project.
There will be 5-6 routes:
1) Sathorn - Lad Pho - Phra Padaeng - Samut Prakarn (17 km). This route
will pass Lad Pho shortcut canal which will be dug wider to accommodate
more boats. This route also shorten the time for those who live in Samut
Prakarn can go downtown by 1 hour. Either the Chao Phraya Expressboat
or the new private firm will run this boat service.
2) Sathorn - Dao Khanong (Daon Khanong Canal - canal with lots of barges
- the starting point of Suksawat Road) - 4.87 km - 3.56 million baht
3) Memorial Bridge - Phetkasem 20 (Bangkok Noy - Phaseecharoen canal)
- 4.86 km 4.41 million baht
4) Sathorn - Rat Boorana - Klong Toei [Customs Department] (New line of
Chao Phraya Express boat) - 16 km - 6.72 million baht
5) Saensaeb boat canal improvement (Phan Fah - Wat Sri Bun Ruean)
The new prototype boats will be made of fiberglass--5-10 boats with a
price of 4-5 million baht. Initially, the government will start the project.
If the private sector feels interested, the Marine Department will call
a new bid.
According to the advice from Golden Plan Co.Ltd and Potential Engineering
Consultant Co.Ltd, there are six potential canal-river routes such as
1) Sathorn - Dao Khanong
2) Memorial Bridge - Phetkasem 20 (total for 2 routes > 10,000 passengers
a day)
3) Sathorn - Klong Toei
4) Phan Fah - Wat Sri Bunruean
5) Sathorn - Lad Pho Canal
6) Lad Pho Canal - Samut Prakarn (total > 80,000 passengers a day)
Commentary by Wisarut: The Samrong Extension of Skytrain has ended
any further need for Chao Phraya express boats to Sanphawut Pier (Naval
Ordinance Pier, Bang Na). Only motorcycle taxis and feeder buses around
that area would feed passengers to either Udomsuk or Bang NA station.
Hopefully the Paknam extension of the Skytrain will terminate not far
from the pier in Paknam. This could be a feeder boat to the Skytrain.
The Memorial Bridge to Phetkasem 20 route could feed the Memorial Bridge
Station of MRTA.
Dao Khanong pier and Daokhanong station of future Subway should not be
far away from each other.
Even though Saen Saeb canal boat piers are not far from the Skytrain and
Subway stations (National Stadium, Phetburi), the facilities must be improved
so as to function as feeders.
[Notice how this canal plan conflicts with the recently proposed mass
transit routes.] BMA will need to redesign the future Rattankosin extension
so as not to block Saensaeb canal boat service.
Expanding the canal and Chao Phraya
boat network - translated and summarized by Wisarut
Bholsithi from Matichon Daily, October 18, 2003
MOTC Minister has asked the Deputy Director of the Marine Department about
the plan to extend the Chao Phraya Express Boat as well as the longtail
boats along the canals. MOTC also asks for new prototypes for canal boats
and the Chao Phraya Express Boat.
MOTC also aims for a Chao Phraya Express Boat to Samut Prakarn. However
the initial routes will be shorter. The list of the routes will be:
1) Sathon-Dao Khanong - 4.87 km
2) Memorial Bridge-Phetkasem 20 (Phaseecharoen)
3) Sathon-Klong Toei (Custom Department) - 16 km -> the first phase
of the Chao Phraya Express Boat expansion to Samut Prakarn
4) Saensaeb Canal - 17 km
Commentary by Wisarut: MOTC aims to take over the BMA-consessioned
Saensaeb canal boat.
The new Chao Phraya boat line from Sathorn to Klong Toei will help in
picking up passengers not covered by either Skytrain or Subway. The new
boat line from Sathorn to Dao Khanong is pretty short--it is uncertain
how many passengers it could pick up.
500 billion baht mass transit system
to be complete in six years - translated and
summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Thairath, October 16, 2003
The Traffic Policy Office said the following mass transit
lines with a total distance of 255 km should be completed in six years:
1) BMA - BTSC Skytrain network - 39.70 km, 75.86 billion baht to be done
in 1-6 years
1.1) Onnut - Samrong (Samrong Extension) - to be done in December 2006
1.2) Samrong - Samut Prakarn (Paknam Extension - AKA Samrong Extension
Phase 2) -> by popular demand
1.3) Saphan Taksin - Taksin Road (Taksin Extension) - to be done in December
2004
1.4) Taksin Road - Phetkasem (Phekasem Extension - AKA Taksin Extension
Phase 2)
1.5) Mochit - Saphan Mai (Phaholyothin Extension) -> by popular demands,
but the giant water pipeline must be moved to another place and the demolition
of the Senanikom flyover is needed
1.6) National Stadium - Rama I Road - Sanam Luang - Pinklao - Charansanitwongse
(Ratthanakosin Extension)
2) MRTA - BMCL subway network
2.1) Blue Line Network - 39 km - 66.97 billion baht to be done in 5-7
years
2.1.1) Hua Lamphong - Tha Phra (Underground Section of Southern Extension)
2.1.2) Bangsue - Tha Phra (Northern Ring)
2.1.3) Tha Phra - Bang Wah (The Elevated Connection with Interchange with
Skytrain)
2.1.4) Bang Wah - Bang Kae (Kanchanaphisek Link of Southern Extension)
2.1.5) Bang Khae - Om Noy (Further Southern Extension)
2.2) Orange Line - 23 km - 56.260 billion baht
2.2.1) Bangkapi - Thai Cultural Center - Victory Monument - Samsen [Sang
Hee]
2.2.2) Samsen [Sang Hee] - Krungthon Bridge - Bang Bamru Railway Station
(Krung Thon Extension)
2.3) Purple Line Network - 39.2 km - 81.473 billion baht
2.3.1) Bang Yai - Phra Nang Klao [Bang Yai Extension]
2.3.2) Phra Nangklao - Bangsue [former Northern Extension of Blue Line
Subway]
2.3.3) Bangsue - Samsen [The underground section of former Purple Line]
2.3.4) Samsen - Ratboorana (Nakhon Khuenkhan Intersection) [former middle
and Southern
section of Orange Line]
3) SRT - 114.51 km Red Line Network - 108.1 Billion Baht - to be done
in 5 years
3.1) Phyathai - Makkasan - Phetburi - NBIA (Airport Train)
3.2) Bangsue - Phayathi (Chitladda Link)
3.3) Hua Lamphong - Bangsue (Share Track with Chitladda Link)
3.4) Bangsue - Rangsit (Northern Commuter)
3.5) Hualamphong - Si Phraya - Wongwian Yai - Taksin Center (Southern
Link)
3.6) Taksin Center - Mahachai (Mahachai Extension)
3.7) Bangsue - Talingchan (Rama 6 Extension)
Furthermore, a 100 billion baht nationwide double tracking project is
proposed.
The Traffic Office will submit the plan to the cabinet on October 22,
2003 before getting final approval from Premier Thaksin.
Commentary by Wisarut: Too bad the Northern Section of the former
Purple line (Taopoon - Prachachuen - Maungthongthani - Pakkret) is not
included in the MRTA Purple network. Relying on feeder buses and feeder
vans along Prachachuen Road and expressway may not be enough.
Nationwide double tracking is very good deal .... and the nationwide new
excise tax on fuel and vehicle license plates will be reasonable if the
100-billion baht double tracking project is included.
The overall mass transit project requires massive money and effort as
well as excellent management to ensure that all will be finished on time
- an effort on par with building after the collapse of Ayutthaya, the
wreckage after WWII, and revitalization after financial meltdown of 1997.
Foreign investment to set up the local assembly lines to handle the rolling
stocks (Skytrain - Subway - Commuters and Airport Train) as well as the
restructuring of relating agencies should be mandatory.
I hope that the further lines such as Bangkapi - Minburi (Minburi Extension
of Orange line), Nakhon Khuenkhan - Samrong Tai (Phra Padaeng extension
of Purple line Network), Pakkret - Muangthong Thani - Bangsue (Pakkret
Extension of Purple line Network), and Yellow Line (Lad Phrao - Sri Nakharin
- Samrong) will be implemented to complete the network.
I also hope that the savings from the Wayuphak Mutual Funds will go into
the project without being siphoned into the pockets of contractors and
politicians. After all, many politicians used to work as contractors before
entering into politics. Mr. Banharn (Mr. Midget or Deng Siaw Harn - the
head of Chatchai Party) is a good example of a contractor-turned politician.
Bidding for the southern extension will be held in April
2004 - translated and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi
from Matichon Daily, October 15, 2003
The bidding forms for the Southern Kanchanaphisek Outer Ring Road are purchased
by two contractors. The project will have a total distance of 22.49 km and
a price tag of 16 billion baht. The bidding will be called on December 15,
2003 and the qualified contractors will be declared on December 16, 2003.
The Mall Group keen on SRT land for
Megaprojects - translated and summarized by Wisarut
Bholsithi from Thansetthakij,
October 16-18, 2003
The Mall Group PCL told the press that they definitely going to aim for
three megaproject malls -> Makkasan Airport Link, MRTA Subway, and
Suvannabhum Airport Mall. The Mall Group is going to invest 500 million
baht to make a face lift on the Emporium, The Mall Bang Kapi and The Mall
Ngam Wongwan. Furthermore, the Siam Paragon Group (Subsidiary of The Mall)
is investing 30 million baht to turn Bangkok into a city of Fashion on
par with Milan and Paris.
At Makkasan, the Airport Link Mall will be on the 80-rai of the old housing
and Railway Hospital for SRT workers. The new Mall at NBIA will a duty
free mall inside the NBIA. However the Mall will make such a move only
after finishing the Siam Paragon.
The Mall Group forecasts 28 billion baht revenue--an increase from 25
billion baht in the previous year with 10% Growth. If there is no economic
recession or other disaster, the Mall Group projects to grow 15-20%.
The plan for the next year (2004) is to make a 500 million baht investment
for a comprehensive facelift of the Emporium with a new parking lot which
can hold 500 more cars. Furthermore, the Mall is going to add other 5
mini-cinema rooms for the SF Cinema at The Mall Ngam Wongwan, and make
a facelift of The Mall Bang Kapi to become a Flagship Store and add other
5 mini-cinema rooms for the SF Cinema. [BTW, The Mall Bang Kapi is a big
magnet of those who live in Bang Kapi area - with a van hub, bus terminal
and Saensabe canal boat.]
The Mall Group, Siam Discovery Center Siam Center and Siam Paragon will
invest 30 million baht on the "Bangkok Fashion City Extravaganza"
Project (7-Day Fashion Show in February 2004) as the way to turn Bangkok
into a major fashion hub like Milan and Paris complying with government
policy. It will also start the current of creating a Shopping Street from
Pathumwan to Asok/Sukhumvit. This project in February 2004 will have 80-100
world-class brandname products as well as local brand names.
Suriya aiming to use 23 billion baht
Wayuphak Funds for the airport link insisting that Premier Thaksin supports
the project - translated and summarized by Wisarut
Bholsithi from Matichon Daily, October 15, 2003
Suriya is aiming to pull 23 billion baht from Wayuphak Funds to construct
the airport train and claiming that Premier Thaksin is supporting this
project. He hopes that the annual revenue will be 1.46 billion baht--break
even and get paid back easily. Even if the Ministry of Finance is standing
in the way to oppose this scheme, he will push this project at all costs.
The Director of Public Debt Management told Ministry Suriya about the
funding plan for Southern Kanchanaphisek Road and that there are two contractors
who purchase the bidding forms.
On October 13, Minister Suriya Juengrungrueangkij told the press about
the plan to invest 900 billion baht on public transportation and that
Premier Thaksin asked to use Wayuphak Funds to invest in this project
- but a discussion between the agencies related to public transportation
is needed to come up with details for funding the project.
Premier Thaksin and Minister Suriya said funding the 900-billion baht
project by Wayuphak funds is a good deal since it will not increase the
national debt and there is no need for foreign loans with strings attached,
just simply use the saving deposits which now literally flood local banks
with trillions of baht.
The initial phase of the airport train will start from Makkasan to NBIA
with a price tag of 23 billion baht with funding by Wayuphak funds with
the 4% return to the people who buy Wayuphak mutual funds. The estimated
daily customers will be 20,000 and the ticket price for the express will
be 200 baht--4 million baht daily revenue and 1.46 billion baht annual
revenue. The concession will be 30 years, thus the total revenue will
be 43.8 billion baht, easily paying back the mutual funds.
If the Ministry of Finance refuses to allow MOTC to dip into the Wayuphak
funds, he will explain that MOF does not know the project details since
the Traffic Policy Office has not finished the final plan yet. If MOF
still refuses to fund the project, he will ask Premier Thaksin to apply
his executive power to force MOF to finance the project at all costs!
Pannee Sathawarodom (Director of Public Debt Management Dept, MOF) said
the financial plan for such mammoth projects (900 billion baht) requires
(1) loans from financial markets, (2) privatization of MRTA, SRT, and
MEA, and (3) Wayuphak funds. However, MOF will wait and see the final
plan for the mass transit project before making a decision as to whether
MOF will allow MOTC to use Wayuphak funds, and it will take MOF at least
six months to make such a decision.
The funding scheme for this transportation project will come from petroleum
and energy conservation funds collected from excise tax of fuel by changing
the main propose from the funds from fuel subsidies to a fund for joint
investment funds since the new transportation systems must support energy
conservation and encourage the efficient consumption of fuel and energy.
The other financial source will come from people selling the investment
units (mutual funds) just like Wayuphak 1 - with a new Mutual Fund exclusively
for transportation affairs. This new transportation funds will save lots
of money and will not cause a debt burden.
Isan CEO
governors ask SRT for high speed railway expansion to Ubon
- translated and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Thansetthakij,
October 12-15, 2003
After CEO governors started working on October 1, 2003, the Southern Isan
governors from Si Saket, Yasothon, Amnart Charoen and Ubon Ratchathanee
have come with a plan to lift southern Isan from abject poverty to prosperity.
One of the projects is the expansion of the High Speed Railway from Khorat
to Ubon Ratchathanee since Ubon Ratchathanee is 300 km from Khorat. This
High Speed Railway will help link the tourist business in the 'Emerald
Triangle' (Thailand, Laos, Cambodia) with Ubon Ratchathanee as the center
for this link.
Commentary by Wisarut: Very good idea since the total distance
between Bangkok and Ubon Ratchathanee by rail is about 575 km (compare
to Tokaido Shinkansen -> 515 km from Tokyo to Osaka). However, SRT
has to set up a subsidiary as well as a concession holder who would run
the subsidiary to handle such a mammoth project which requires state-of-the-art
technology and future expansions. Now, even country folks are demanding
a High Speed Railway. However, profitable lines will come first!
Injecting 500 billion baht into mass
transit: Traffic Policy Office modifying 6-year plan for 7 Skytrain-Subway
lines - translated and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi
from Thansetthakij, October 12-15, 2003
Traffic Policy Office is pushing the seven lines of electrified mass transit
system with a price tag of 500 billion baht to be done in 6 years [incredible!]
to boost the number of mass transit passengers from 3% to more than 30%.
Another 400 billion baht will be used for the motorway and the suburb road
expansion.
Of the 500 billion baht budget, 350 billion baht was allocated for the rails
in urban areas while the other 150 billion baht is for the rails in suburb
areas.
Government will fund 50% of 900 billion baht while the rest will come from
the profits after breaking even as a way to pay back the government.
The Traffic Policy Office recommended that agencies that have lots of problems
have to be resolved before realizing the projects:
1) BMA has a problem about procurement to support BTSC.
2) MRTA has lots of work handling the Southern extension, the other extensions,
the new Orange line, and the commercial development
3) SRT is VERY weak organization with inept administration and management.
The government will need to help all of these agencies to enable and empower
them to handle the projects without problems. Furthermore, it is necessary
to construct an electrified railway line with double tracks between Bangkok
and the new city in Nakhon Nayok.
The seven lines will be as follows:
1) MRTA Blue line
1.1) MRTA Southern Extension of Blue line- Hua Lamphong - Tha Phra - Bangkhae
-> Ready to call a new bid.
1.2) MRTA Northern Extension of Blue line - Bangsue - Wong Sawang - Phra
Nangklao - Bang Yai -> Has a blueprint.
1.3) MRTA Northern Ring - Bagsue - Banplad - Pinklao - Tha Phra -> Need
to modify the blueprint to correct 'errors.'
2) MRTA Orange Line - Bang Kapi - Ratboorana -> Has a blueprint.
3) SRT Red line
3.1) SRT Airprot Link -> Makkasan - NBIA with the expansion plan to Bangsue
and connect with SRT Red line commuter
3.2) SRT Red Line Commuter -> Bangsue - Rangsit with a plan to expand
to Lopburi
3.3) SRT Red Line Commuter Phase 2 -> Bangsue - Talingchan (along with
Rama 6 Expressway)
3.3) SRT Red line Commuter Phase 3 [not sure if it the same as the High
Speed Railway to Khorat - but very related to Bangsue - Nakhon Nayok)
4) [BTSC-MRTA] Sanam Luang - Charansanitwongse (Green line)
5) [MRTA] Bangsue - Sanghee - Bang Bumru (Orange line branch)
6) BTSC Taksin Extension (1st phase to Taksin Intersection and 2nd phase
to Bang Wah and connect with the Blue line)
7) BTSC Samrong extension (1st phase to Samrong Tai and 2nd phase to Paknam)
Now there are four consulting companies which are qualified to deal with
the Red line commuter -
1) Asian Engineering Consultant Co. Ltd.
2) Team consulting Engineering and Management Co. Ltd.
3) STS Engineering Consultant Co. Ltd.
4) Southeast Asia Technology Co. Ltd.
Commentary by Wisarut: MOTC need to find the way to enable SRT to
handle such massive projects in addition to the transfer of SRT land to
the Treasury Dept.
The Traffic Policy Office should take the popular demands into account -
such as the demands from those who live in Northern Bangkok suburbs to have
the new lines pass thorough the very dense population as the lines that
pass through the magnet places (e.g. Markets, Convention Centers, Universities,
Malls, etc.) to gain more passengers. They should not just be thinking about
the routes with the lowest cost to implement.
Expansion of Northern Commuter to Lopburi is a good idea. After all it is
about 133 km from Bangkok (Hua Lamphong) to Lopburi and there are daily
commuter services between Bangkok and Lopburi. Commuter lines to Nong Pladuk,
Chachoengsao, and Kaeng Khoi would be very good.
Expressway Authority not ready for
the transfer of the tollway-motorway system from the Highway Dept.
- translated and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Dailynews,
October 13, 2003
The Highway Department has sent a letter to the Expressway Authority of
Thailand on May 29, 2003 related to the Southern section of Kanchanapisek
(Bang Plee - Suksawat) as well as the transfer of the following motorways
to the Expressway Authority:
1) Highway No. 7 (Bangkok - Chonburi Motorway)
2) Highway No. 9 (Eastern Kanchanapisek Outer Ring Road -> Bang Pa
In - Bang Plee)
3) Donmuang Tollway (National Memorial - Rangsit)
However, ETA is not ready to take over the motorways until the end of
2003.
The government has a clear policy to transfer all tollways and motorways
to be under the jurisdiction of the Expressway Authority as a way to cut
corruption at the Highway Dept. However, there is red tape due to contracts
between Donmuang Tollway and the Highway Department as well as other relating
issues. Such problems require usage of the Transfer of Motorway Administration
Act and will take a very long time to implement. Using a Motorway Administration
Decree is a quicker substitute. The transfer is intended to reduce corruption
and increase highway system integration.
Compare this to a more generalized article in the Post: Motorway
transfers make slow progress
SRT land to be transferred to the Treasury
Dept to write off 40 billion baht SRT debts -
translated and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Thairath Daily,
October 13, 2003
Minister Suriya told the press that the government has a policy to ask
the Treasury Department to set up an asset management company to efficiently
manage public land including SRT land since SRT has no management skills
to handle the commercial development on SRT land. Only the land for railway
affairs will under the the jurisdiction of SRT.
The Treasury Department must handle all commercial worthy SRT land, not
just the auspicious land such as Central Plaza Lad Phrao--otherwise SRT
will refuse to grant the land to Treasury Department.
SRT will reserve land at Makkasan and Phaholyothin-Bangsue for itself
since SRT has a plan supported by the government to construct the new
Makkasan Station for the Airport Link and the new Bangsue-Phaholyothin
Station for the urban railway center.
SRT land at Ratchadaphisek Inner Ring Road will be given away to the Treasury
Department, but the Treasury Department has to pay SRT according to market
rates; otherwise, Treasury Department has to ask the Ministry of Finance
to use the land price at Ratchadaphisek as the credit to write off SRT's
debts of 40-billion baht. However, SRT will cooperate with the Ministry
of Finance to deal on the land price assessment by submitting details
on SRT land which will be done by the end of October and then call a bid
for the land assessment.
The transfer of SRT land will involve land zoning between SRT land with
commercial viability and land belonging to stations. The first phase of
land transfer will focus on auspicious land with the contract between
SRT and private firms such as Central Plaza Lad Phrao and the land around
Ratchadaphisek Inner Ring Road.
However, the vast majority of SRT land is still plagued with land encroachment
by slum dwellers (e.g. those who live around Eastern Railway from Yommaraj
to Hua Mark and Klong Toei). SRT will have to make a discussion with NHA
and the Treasury Department about a plan to deal with those slum dwellers.
After transferring the SRT land (except Makkasan and Bangsue-Phaholyothin),
SRT will be focusing on revenue generating from the railway business--especially
the cargo transportation.
Commentary by Wisarut: I hope that the land transfer to Treasury
Department will be a successful deal to write off SRT debts. Probably,
SRT should consider transforming debts into assets by allowing creditors
such as PTT Pcl. to hold SRT stocks.
Suriya follows the pattern of China
Railway and JR to develop SRT - translated and
summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Manager Daily, October 7,
2003
Minister Suriya told the press that SRT has to improve railway capabilities
to transport products and passengers and is asking the Japanese government
(Ministry of Transportation) to send railway experts to advise SRT about
how to improve railway systems. Minister Suriya is also going to Japan
in late October to see the managing system and the railway development
as well as rail links to the airports (Narita Express, Keisei Skyliner,
etc etc).
After that, Minister Suriya is going to see railway technology developed
China Railway (State Enterprise Under the Jurisdiction of the Railway
Ministry) as well as the Australian Railway to gather information to come
up with a plan for optimal investment to improve the SRT railway system
and enable SRT top become a money maker again.
To gain more revenue, the central government has to invest on SRT more.
According to the target, the speed for the passenger train must be more
than 160 kph. If SRT still uses the current structure which allows a maximum
speed of 60-80 kph, it will bankrupt the SRT within 5 years.
Therefore, the new tracks for passengers - especially the one connecting
with China should be the Standard Gauge [1.4351 m - 4 feet and 8.5 inches]
and the old meter gauge tracks will be used exclusively for cargo transportation.
However, the government needs to come up with a good plan before making
such a huge investment. Otherwise, it will duplicate the investment -
SRT will still be loss-ridden even after pouring trillions of baht of
investment into new bad rail systems.
SRT still has a duty to lay the track nationwide while MRTA will handle
all the mass transit system within Greater Bangkok with private concessions
for service and public investment on basic infrastructure.
MOTC also studies the maintenance system and technology for developing
local versions of locomotives as a way to make the comprehensive railway
improvement. Furthermore, the government will invite the foreign investors
who are experts on railway systems to make a joint venture with the Thai
government to improve the railway system--with competitive bidding. So
far Siemens has grabbed BTSC Skytrain and MRTA Subway in their portfolio.
However, MOTC wants more choices from Canadian Bombadier (which has taken
over the German Adranz), the Chain Railway Corp. (state enterprise from
the Ministry of Railway), and railways companies from Japan and Australia.
Commentary by Wisarut: Additional standard gauge tracks with continuous
welding rails are very expensive.
High society hoarding land around ramps
of the proposed elevated way - translated and
summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Prachachart Thurakij, October
9-12, 2003
[Again: Try finding any mention of something like this in the local
English-language papers!]
Charoen Siriwatthanaphakdee (the owner of Beer Chang), Angkinan (the baron
or the don of Phetburi), the Juengrungruengkit family (Transportation
Minister Suriya's family), Red Bull Group, and San Yang Food Industry
Co. Ltd. (the owner of Ladybug Dried Squid) are hoarding land around the
ramps of the Laem Phak Bia [the
elevated way over the sea]. The area on the sea shore is now 8 million
baht a rai. Now most locals people agree that the project will be good
for them. However, conflicts of interest as well as untransparent methods
will be a big source of corruption and collusion.
The Laem Phak Bia project proposed by Premier Thaksin has boosted the
land development plan from Laem Phak Bia Commune in Ban Laem district
to Cha Am district of Phetburi from the doldrums after the economic meltdown
in 1997. 90% of local people are fishermen and the shrimp and the salt
fields belong to the Angkinan family (the don of Phetburi). Now the Angkinan
family has made a joint venture with Charoen Siriwatthanaphakdee (the
owner of Beer Chang) on a seafood processing plant as well as a resort
and seafood restaurants on 1600 rai of land long the shore.
The commune head as well as the local fishermen support this project.
20 years ago, the land was 30,000 baht/rai. Today it is eight million
baht/rai.
Even Samut Sakhon is getting stampeded by capitalists who come to hoard
the land along the route. People of Samut Sakhon have no objection to
this project, but need to have the project transparent to prevent corruption
and collusion. Now people feel suspect about the project since Prapokklao
Institute asks the local people to come up with a public hearing even
though the institute has the duty to handle the public hearing.
The Samut Sakhon chamber of commerce has become a supporter of the project
since they can set up the business to support passengers. Only those Democrat
MPs in Phetburi come to protest against the project and have flaming venom
against the Thai Rak Thai Party.
Commentary by Wisarut: Mr Charoen is also hoarding land around
Ban Nah for the new city while those who hoard land around Sanamchaikhet
such as the Tancharoen family (family of Deputy Speaker Suchard Tancharoen)
wants to revive the new city at Sanamchaikhet. The other new city area
is around Pasak Cholasit Dam where the land is hoarded by the House Speaker
Uthai's family. [More about this: Muang Sawan project (Celestial
City Project) at Ban Nah - translated and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi
from Naew Nah, September 30, 2003]
Songkhla
Lake restoration--Elevated road to be first project
- Bangkok Post, October 3, 2003
(Photo:2Bangkok.com) |
Thai reporters compare Bangkok
and Shanghai - translated and summarized
by Wisarut Bholsithi from Dailynews, September 29, 2003
After visiting Shanghai - which is in 6,000 sq-km (4 times the size
of Bangkok) with a population of 16 million, we found that Shanghai
has a complex network of expressways--5 layers of expressways in
the inner city. The roads in Shanghai are 4-6 lanes with dedicated
lanes for bicycles, electric bicycles, and motorcycles. |
The total length of roads in Shanghai is about 6829 km
for 1.6 million cars, 9 million bicycles, and 2 millions drivers with driver
licenses. Their roads have very few potholes.
Shanghai has two sides separated by the Haung Pu river--Shanghai and Pu
Dong. Putong side is a new city with very good planning. All the power lines
are underground. All waterworks and electricity lines are planned and executed
at the same time.
For the buses, the air-conditioned bus is 15-20 baht and very close to the
Shanghai Metro system. The regular bus is 7.50 baht. All the buses we have
seen in Shanghai look pretty news since the local authority has limited
the lifetime of those vehicles to 10 years. Replacement is not a problem
since 80% of the vehicles are made in China [either local brands or licensed
versions from automobile giants], thus the air in Shanghai is less polluted
than Bangkok.
Just the expressways in Shanghai alone are 500 km and there is a ring expressway
which allows traffic to move from one end of the city to another without
going through the city center. Even Hangchow which is a main tourist town
near Shanghai has 164 km of expressways. The city section of the expressways
is free. Drivers will pay only for the Intercity Expressway [Motorway].
There are four giant bridges across the Huang Pu with 12 traffic lanes.
There are 3 underwater tunnels under the river. One tunnel with a People
Mover (15 people at a time) and the other two are for cars--1 inbound and
the other outbound.
For the Shanghai Metro, it consists of both underground and elevated skytrains
as well as a Meglev from Pu Tong International Airport to Shanghai Metro
Line 2. However, the ticket price for the Maglev is very expensive--500
baht a trip due to the fact that the expense for the construction was 1.7
billion baht/km. Shanghai Metro [3 lines] was constructed in 1996 with a
total distance of 100 km.
At People Square Station, the first underground floor [Ticket purchasing
floor] is definitely a mini department store with a bar beer with a climate
of the Bund. The TVMs are identical to the ones for BTSC due to the fact
that Siemens has supplied Shanghai Metro with TVMs and rolling stock - as
well as setting up local assembly lines.
The 2nd floor is the platform. It is an open platform without screen doors.
For now, there are no restrooms in the stations, but the restrooms will
be constructed soon due to passenger demands. They will be vending restrooms
(need to put the coins in).
According to the masterplan, Shanghai will have 9 mass transit lines with
total distance of 500 km
by the end of 2007 to enable passengers to go from one end to another end
in 45 minutes.
We believe that the Shanghai government can do as they say since they have
an assembly line ready to construct the licensed rolling stocks to meet
passenger demand. Nanjing Road and Shenyang market in Shanghai have trolley
buses running as feeders.
For Shanghai, even a slight traffic jam is very big news and pushes both
local and the central government to take immediate action such as limited
days for driving, odd/even number license plate driving rules, restrictions
for vehicles from other cities.
Purchasing a car in Shanghai is a very expensive affair. Just the license
plate alone is 200,000 baht and the annual compulsory checkups cost 50,000
baht. After 10 years, drivers have to buy a new car and obtain a new license.
Drivers licenses carry a point system for checking. Once a driver runs out
of points there is a three year suspension from driving. No lifetime driver
license here.
The only mess we see are bicycles and cars going across red lights, going
against traffic flow, honking horns, etc.
There are no flyovers in Shanghai--only crossings with pedestrians and armies
of bicycles. There are only traffic volunteers to direct. 800 CCTVs to check
6000 intersections so that they will have evidence to issue tickets that
are delivered to their home by mail.
The Communist Party of China has emphasized railed mass transit and use
their absolute power to implement the system while allowing foreign investors
to help the government and people to get know-how to implement the system
to world standards. There is no need to implement public hearings and protests
(like in Thailand) which please highbrow and rotten intellectuals and delay
the projects for years.
At least Premier Thaksin has come up with 136 km of mass transit system
in 6 years for the better life of Bangkokians. We are fed up with those
arguments against it. Just DO it--no need to listen those highbrow rotten
junk...
Land speculation in Pakkret-Nonthaburi--even
vacant land is now 7 million baht/rai - translated
and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Prachachart Turakij, October
2-5, 2003
Contractors and land agents are scrambling for land near expropriated
land for the Pakkret Bridge connecting with Highway 345 (the road from
Rama 5 Bridge-Ratnathibet). Even though the project is not started yet,
land prices skyrocketed from 2000-3000 baht/square wah (0.8-1.2 million
baht/rai) to 5-7 million baht/rai.
The Department of Rural Roads has
just signed a 3 billion baht contract with the contractor for the Pakkret
Bridge and the connecting roads Capitalists, land agents, and contractors
are hoarding land around the roads for real estate speculation.

Graphic from Prachachart Turakij, October 2-5, 2003
There are lots of people involved in land speculation even though the
land is still paddy fields and orchards. The plan to construct the new
public projects will get a big boost now the land around Rama 5 Bridge
has been priced upward and new suburb villages have mushroomed--especially
the brandname projects (from big guns like Land and House PCL).
The Director of Rural Road Dept said the Department has already expropriated
all the land for the new bridges and roads and signed a contract with
the contractors for the 3 billion baht Pakkret Project on September 29,
2003--after JBIC granted the loan and the cabinet approved the project
on September 23, 2003. The project fund has been capped at 3 billion baht
and the project will be done in 2006.
After project is done, it will help the traffic in western and southern
Bangkok since this project will definitely connect with Rama 5 Bridge
at Rattanathebet and Kanchanaphisek Outer Ring Road. The traffic around
Tiwanon and Chaeng Watthana Road will also get some relief since vehicles
will get to Nuanchawee Bridge faster boosting the network at Rama
5 Bridge [AKA Nakhon In Bridge].
The southern section of the new project will connect with the northern
end of Nakhon In Bridge at Rattnathibet. The northern end of the new project
will be at Highway 345 with a total distance of 7.7 km. The road will
be 60 km long--6 traffic lanes with a middle island. There will be an
interchange at Highway 345 and the Phra Udom Canal [the East-West and
North-South Section].
The East-West Road will go from Chaeng Watthana Road at Pakkret Intersection
[5-limb Star Intersection] connecting with North-South Road with a total
distance of 6.1 km. The road will be 60 km long--6 traffic lanes with
a middle island. The East-West road will have a 2.6-km bridge--56-meters
wide for the western and eastern ramp and 94-meter wide at the center
of the bridge.
Commentary by Wisarut: This project will need to be ensure that
it will be no detrimental effect on Koh Kret--the green island in Chaophraya
River with a Mon Community and with a leaning Raman Pagoda with the inscription
of King Chulalongkorn for his great grand mother who used to reside in
Koh Kret.
Also Wat Kooh, a temple near the place where a tragedy happened in May
1880. A boat capsized at Pakkret had killed the pregnant Queen Sunsdakumarirat
and her daughter. This tragedy compelled King Chulalongkorn to build a
memorial at Bang Pa In Summer Palace, the stupa at Saranrom Palace (now
Sararom Park near the Grand Palace and Wat Poh), and a pyramid containing
the ashes of the queen and her children at Phriew Waterfall, Chanthaburi.
13 billion baht needed for realizing
a northern transportation center - translated
and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Dailynews, September 29,
2003
After a discussion with the PM on September 10 about mass transit development,
the Traffic Policy Office has asked MRTA and related agencies about the
plan to reach a goal of 136 km mass transit lines [including 115 commuter
lines] within 6 years. For sections that MRTA has a blueprint, the bidding
should be called immediately. The lines without blueprints will have to
be designed as soon as possible.
For the Northern Bangkok Transportation Center connecting Bangkok with
the northern and Isan regions as well as some Central and Eastern provinces,
it will be on 2000-Rai of SRT land which is now used by the Transportation
Co. Ltd. for Mochit 2 and BMTA as a terminal. The designer will be appointed
on October 6, 2003 and the Traffic Policy Office will push the project
forward to be done in 3 years.
Commentary by Wisarut: I hope that this hub will connect with the
Skytrain and subway in addition to the railway.
Songkhla
Lake restoration--Elevated road to be first project
- Bangkok Post, October 3, 2003
700-million-baht elevated road bypassing Thale Noi in Khuan Khanun
district will be the first project under the four-year Songkhla Lake restoration
plan.
"The 17.5km road would ease transportation between Songkhla's Ranot
district and Phatthalung's Khuan Khanun district,'' Prime Minister Thaksin
Shinawatra said during a trip to the area yesterday...
The new route, to be known as Pracha Dhamma road, will shorten the journey
from 90km to 30km.
Muang Sawan
project (Celestial City Project) at Ban Nah
- translated and summarized by Wisarut Bholsithi from Naew Nah, September
30, 2003
Mass Transit News main page |